You believe you’re doing something good as a leader. You end up stressing them out instead.
I have been nerding out on a cluster of 2026 leadership studies, and several of them made me stop and say, “Wait. What?”
Not because the research argues that common leadership practices are bad. Quite the opposite.
Empower people. Ask for feedback. Invite ideas. Remove unnecessary work. Give people more ownership.
Those are things many of us have been taught good leaders should do, right?
Alas, the research shows we can make a reasonable, well-intended leadership move and still create pressure we did not expect.
The same leadership move does not create the same experience for everyone.
That does not mean leaders need to predict every possible employee reaction. And employees are part of the equation too. They bring their own assumptions, fears, past experiences, and pressure into what happens next.
The interesting part is what happens in between. A leader does something. An employee interprets what it means.
And sometimes, what feels like good leadership from one side feels very different from the other. That is what makes these next four findings so interesting.
1. Wait, what? Giving people more power can also give them more stress.
We are told to empower people. Give them more autonomy. More ownership. More room to make decisions.
Then I came across a 2026 study from Xun Liu and his colleagues at Suzhou University of Science and Technology. They surveyed 356 construction professionals working in high-pressure project environments.
They found something I did not expect: Empowering leadership encouraged people to speak up more. Great! It also increased two different kinds of stress:
- One kind of stress pushed people to rise to the challenge and offer more ideas.
- The other made the work feel harder to navigate and made people less likely to speak up.
So the same move can sound like this to one employee: She trusts me. I finally have room to run.
And like this to another: Wait. I’m responsible for this now? What if I get it wrong?
That is the part worth paying attention to. Giving someone more ownership changes more than what they are allowed to do. It can also change what they believe they are now responsible for.
So what is really going on?
Do they actually lack the authority, information, or support they need?
Or has uncertainty, fear of failure, or the need to get it exactly right made the responsibility feel heavier than it is?
Those are very different problems. And they need very different responses.
2. Wait, what? Taking work away can make people more exhausted.
This one really struck me.
Annika Schaefer and Kai Bormann at Bielefeld University studied what researchers call “illegitimate tasks,” work people see as unnecessary or unreasonable. Across two diary-style studies, they looked at what happened when that kind of work went up or down.
You would expect the answer to be simple:
- More pointless work = worse.
- Less pointless work = better.
Except that was not quite what they found.
When the amount of unnecessary work changed – even when it went down – people reported more emotional exhaustion than when the workload stayed steady.
Uncertainty helped explain why.
The researchers are not saying we should keep pointless work around. They are saying change itself can create questions.
Imagine I tell someone: Good news. You don’t need to do these reports anymore.
I may be thinking: I just gave you six hours back every month.
They may be thinking: Why? Was that work not valuable? Is my role changing? What are they going to give me instead?
Or even: Should I be worried about my job? …This one is my example, not something the researchers found.
I believe this gets us to a bigger point: Less work and less uncertainty are not the same thing.
As leaders, we cannot own every story someone tells themselves. Yet if we change the work, it is probably worth explaining why.
And as employees, we can notice when uncertainty has turned into a story and ask a question before we start treating that story like a fact.
3. Wait, what? Asking for feedback can eventually make people less likely to speak.
As someone who believes deeply in curiosity, I almost did not want this one to be true.
Ming Lou and colleagues from Harbin Engineering University, Wayne State University, and Harbin Institute of Technology studied what happens when leaders regularly ask employees for feedback. Their research included a multi-wave field study and a separate survey-and-experiment design.
There was good news.
When leaders asked for feedback, employees could feel more valued, and that could make them more willing to speak up.
Alas, there was another side.
As feedback-seeking became excessive, workplace anxiety went up and employee voice could start going down.
Think about how strange that can feel.
A leader is thinking: I want their input. I’m showing that I’m open.
Meanwhile, the employee starts wondering: Why does she keep asking me? Does she not know what to do? Am I supposed to reassure her? Is there a right answer here?
The takeaway is not: stop asking for feedback.
It is simply this: More of a good leadership behavior is not automatically better… Or, “Everything in moderation.”
Sometimes what feels like openness to the leader becomes one more thing the employee feels responsible for managing.
4. Wait, what? Even asking people to speak up can backfire.
This may be my favorite.
Qian Song and colleagues published a 2026 study in the Journal of Organizational Behavior looking at what happens when leaders ask employees to speak up.
Again, you would expect the answer to be obvious. If I ask for your opinion, you should be more likely to give it.
Except the researchers found that it depended a lot on how employees saw the leader. When employees saw the leader as less dominant, being asked for input was more likely to feel like an opportunity.
When they saw the leader as highly dominant, the exact same invitation could feel threatening, increase anxiety, and lead to more silence.
You can say: I really want to know what you think.
One person hears: Permission.
Another hears: Test.
The words did not change. The experience did.
And that is much more useful than simply saying, “People need psychological safety.”
The better question is: What is happening in this relationship that makes the same invitation feel safe to one person and risky to another?
So what is a leader supposed to do?
This is where I do not want us to overcorrect.
- Do not stop empowering people because empowerment can create stress.
- Do not keep pointless work because changing it can create uncertainty.
- Do not stop asking for feedback.
- And definitely do not stop inviting people to speak up.
Pressure cannot be eliminated from meaningful work! Neither can uncertainty, responsibility, disagreement, or the fact that people will interpret things differently.
The goal is not to create a workplace where nobody ever feels uncomfortable.
The opportunity is to stop assuming that what we intended is automatically what someone else experienced.
- You gave someone ownership. What are they experiencing?
- You changed their workload. What are they assuming that change means?
- You asked for feedback. Do they feel valued… or responsible for managing your uncertainty?
- You invited disagreement. Does the way you respond when someone actually disagrees support the invitation?
That is curiosity. Not over-responsibility. And there is another side to this.
Employees have choices too.
Ning Chen and Lu Chen’s 2026 research on performance pressure found that pressure from leaders can transfer to team members through the signals the team picks up. Yet it did not affect everyone in exactly the same way. Empowerment and employees’ beliefs about performance and rewards changed the strength of that effect.
So yes, the signal matters. And so does the person interpreting it.
Which brings me back to the question I use over and over in my work…
What is really going on here?
Not: Whose fault is this?
Instead: What did I intend? What did they experience? Is their reaction telling us something important about the environment? Or has fear, an assumption, or an old pattern made the pressure heavier? And what do we each need to do differently now?
Leadership is not just about choosing the right behavior.
People interpret what we do through their own pressure, assumptions, history, and sense of what is at stake. That makes leadership messier than a list of best practices. It also makes it more human. Because sometimes good intentions really do backfire.
The answer is not to stop trying to lead well. It is to stay curious enough to notice when what you meant to create is not what someone else is experiencing… and then figure out what is really going on before deciding what comes next.
Research Referenced
- Chen, N. & Chen, L. (2026). “Deciphering pressure signals: a cross-level model of performance pressure transmission from team leaders to team members.” Journal of Business Research, 212, 116236. Published July 2026. The ScienceDirect record confirms the finding that leader performance pressure promotes member performance pressure, with team performance-approach goal orientation as a mediator and empowerment/reward expectancy as boundary conditions. View study
- Liu, X., Chen, Z., Zang, J. & Lin, L. (2026). “Impact of empowering leadership on voice behavior of engineering project employees: the mediating role of challenge–hindrance stressors.” International Journal of Occupational Safety and Ergonomics. Published online September 8, 2026. The journal record confirms the 356-person construction-industry sample and the dual finding: empowering leadership increased voice while also increasing both challenge and hindrance stress. View study
- Schaefer, A. & Bormann, K. C. (2026). “The less the better? The effects of changes in illegitimate tasks on exhaustion and uncertainty.” Work & Stress. Published online January 13, 2026. The publisher record confirms that across two experience-sampling studies, both increases and decreases in illegitimate tasks were associated with greater emotional exhaustion versus stable levels, with uncertainty mediating the relationship. View study
- Lou, M., Teng, E., Tekleab, A. G., Zhang, L. & Su, Y. (2026). “Does Leader Feedback-Seeking Behavior Fuel Employee Voice? The Roles of Organization-Based Self-Esteem, Workplace Anxiety and Apparent Sincerity of Leader.” Journal of Organizational Behavior, 47(7), 1090–1108. First published March 16, 2026. The Wiley article confirms both pathways: feedback-seeking can increase voice through organization-based self-esteem, while excessive feedback-seeking can increase workplace anxiety and ultimately undermine voice. View study
- Song, Q., Yang, S., Chen, Y., Ren, S. & Guo, Y. (2026). “When Inviting Voice Backfires: How Leader Dominance Shapes Employee Responses to Voice Solicitation.” Journal of Organizational Behavior, 47(7), 1205–1227. First published January 25, 2026; included in the September 2026 issue. The Wiley record confirms that voice solicitation worked differently depending on perceived leader dominance: lower-dominance leaders were more likely to inspire voice, while higher-dominance leaders could trigger anxiety and silence. View study


